Q: Voicing
Moderators: pompeiisneaks, Colossal
Re: Q: Voicing
There are a number of us on the Hoffman amp forum that use this "enhance cap" across the plate going into the LTPI to smooth out the highs.
This was done on 4 different amps I've had with similar results.
It seems to smooth the highs withOUT eliminating the highs. I can not hear any loss of high frequencies using this.
It also seems to allow more "blooming" on Dumblish inspired amps such as the Tweed Overdrive Special and D'Mars OD special. My unscientific impression is that is removes some of the "hash" (harshness) of the high frequencies which allows the notes to sustain and bloom more smoothly.
IF you try this carefully use insulated alligator clipped wires and values between 82p to 150p across the plate resistor. This is a very quick and easy mod to try.
IF it works on your amp, please post the results so others can know about it.
With respect, 10thtx
This was done on 4 different amps I've had with similar results.
It seems to smooth the highs withOUT eliminating the highs. I can not hear any loss of high frequencies using this.
It also seems to allow more "blooming" on Dumblish inspired amps such as the Tweed Overdrive Special and D'Mars OD special. My unscientific impression is that is removes some of the "hash" (harshness) of the high frequencies which allows the notes to sustain and bloom more smoothly.
IF you try this carefully use insulated alligator clipped wires and values between 82p to 150p across the plate resistor. This is a very quick and easy mod to try.
IF it works on your amp, please post the results so others can know about it.
With respect, 10thtx
You do not have the required permissions to view the files attached to this post.
- Darkbluemurder
- Posts: 584
- Joined: Tue Jan 03, 2006 7:28 pm
Re: Q: Voicing
What you are doing with this enhance cap is stabilize the amp with respect to its negative feedback loop. This is explained in great detail in chapter 9 (feedback theory) in ValveWizard's preamp design book. Definitely a sensible enhancement.
Cheers Stephan
Cheers Stephan
- JazzGuitarGimp
- Posts: 2357
- Joined: Mon Jul 23, 2012 4:54 pm
- Location: Northern CA
Re: Q: Voicing
Is that to say there is nothing to be gained from this mod if the amp doesn't have NFB?Darkbluemurder wrote:What you are doing with this enhance cap is stabilize the amp with respect to its negative feedback loop. This is explained in great detail in chapter 9 (feedback theory) in ValveWizard's preamp design book. Definitely a sensible enhancement.
Cheers Stephan
Lou Rossi Designs
Printed Circuit Design & Layout,
and Schematic Capture
Printed Circuit Design & Layout,
and Schematic Capture
Re: Q: Voicing
Interesting, I just saw this. I actually tried this a couple weeks ago on one of my amps screwing around tweaking and learning wondering what an anode bypass would do on the PI. When I did it, the amp volume dropped, became very fizzy and the EQ was like a telephone. I put it on the other side though, not the primary signal plate resistor.
I wonder if this is signaling a problem with that amp? Without it, it sounds great. So not sure why this happened and I've been meaning to look into that more.
I wonder if this is signaling a problem with that amp? Without it, it sounds great. So not sure why this happened and I've been meaning to look into that more.
Re: Q: Voicing
Surfsup,
Hmm, that's odd. I've done that to a hot rodded Marshall with 4 gain stages and it was a tweak that really took it from great to wow, that's really freakin' great. It improved the separation even more; icing on the cake so to speak. I have a resonance and presence circuit in the feedback loop.
Hmm, that's odd. I've done that to a hot rodded Marshall with 4 gain stages and it was a tweak that really took it from great to wow, that's really freakin' great. It improved the separation even more; icing on the cake so to speak. I have a resonance and presence circuit in the feedback loop.
Re: Q: Voicing
Any chance that you're thinking of Randall Smith of Mesa Boogie rather than Dan Torres? I found out that Mesa Boogie does this on a couple of their amps.
With respect, 10thtx
With respect, 10thtx
Re: Q: Voicing
never mind 
Last edited by M Fowler on Thu Oct 11, 2012 4:18 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Re: Q: Voicing
Newbie question:
Why the cap on one side only?
Why the cap on one side only?
Re: Q: Voicing
Fair question .........Why the cap on one side only?
It worked. That was all that my 4 amps needed.
I prefered the tone of that over having both LTPI sides having caps across the plate resistors (which I also tried). I thought the tone was more articulate and expressive with just the one side.
with respect, 10thtx
Re: Q: Voicing
This is exactly my observation.10thTx wrote:I thought the tone was more articulate and expressive with just the one side.
Re: Q: Voicing
Thanks guys.
Can't beat first hand experience no matter what the MATH says!
Can't beat first hand experience no matter what the MATH says!
Re: Q: Voicing
Thanks for everyone's support. I keep getting sidetracked with other new builds, but still in monitoring this!
A couple notes...the amp is still currently stock as designed, I find the G12H30-70th Anniversary very flat and not a bright speaker at all, I am and have been using a 40'cable over the last year.
As soon as I can, I'd like to get in and Tweak the TW Express to my personal liking. You guys gave me some things to check out and think about. Amp design is funny....you complete a baseline design and then really needs to be tweaked to suit.
Thanks for everyone's help. Back to my new 2-channel design!!
A couple notes...the amp is still currently stock as designed, I find the G12H30-70th Anniversary very flat and not a bright speaker at all, I am and have been using a 40'cable over the last year.
As soon as I can, I'd like to get in and Tweak the TW Express to my personal liking. You guys gave me some things to check out and think about. Amp design is funny....you complete a baseline design and then really needs to be tweaked to suit.
Thanks for everyone's help. Back to my new 2-channel design!!
-
gingertube
- Posts: 531
- Joined: Mon Nov 14, 2011 2:29 am
- Location: Adelaide, South Oz
Re: Q: Voicing
By putting the cap across the first anode load of the PI (input side) you are putting a high frequency roll off on the whole PI - why? becasue the other side of the PI is driven from its cathode by a signal generated by that input side - so the cathode driven side will follow the input side response. For 100K + 100pF the roll off is at 15.9 kHz. At this frequency you are only knocking off some higher order harmonics which tend to be nasty sounding anyway and a bit of high frequency noise. In addition the PI can be subject to supersonic parasitic oscillation, particularly if there is a treble boost just ahead of that stage. This mod will tend to stop parasitic oscillation BUT I still recommend the use of grid stop resistors on both sides of the PI. Might be over the top but I generally use 10K for these.
Putting a cap across the anode load on the other side of the PI (cathode driven side) will be sus (as experienced above) as this will unbalance the PI at high frequencies whether or not you have global NFB.
Cheers,
Ian
Putting a cap across the anode load on the other side of the PI (cathode driven side) will be sus (as experienced above) as this will unbalance the PI at high frequencies whether or not you have global NFB.
Cheers,
Ian
Re: Q: Voicing
^^^This!!
Great post as always Ian.
Great post as always Ian.