Doug H wrote:Most people who diss pedals across the board either don't use them in the proper context or don't really understand how to use them. I have a big set of tools in my toolbox. The task at hand determines which wrench I'll grab today.
There are several "problems" inherent to pedals IMHO:
One, you're inserting a solid state device into your tube signal path. Yes I know the audiophools will go D/A/D and insert a tube into the analog signal path, the signal path is still solid state with the limitations of solid state and worse for instance digital "clipping" is the nastiest noise out there.
Two, classic pedals are built down to a price not up to a standard. There's an old greeting that goes "May the ground rise to meet you", as a biker that's the
last thing I want to see! The traditional pedal bugaboo is that the noise floor rises with every pedal you insert into the signal path and your available bandwidth may be reduced with each additional pedal. The boutique pedal guys understand this, that's the difference between a fifty buck pedal and a two hundred dollar pedal "that does the same thing".
Why drop a couple grand on a good guitar and a couple more grand for a good amp then stick some crappy tone sucker in between?
Ah, tone suckers. That's Aspen Pittman's term. I guess there's a thing or two good ol' Aspen just doesn't get. He thinks effect loops all suck tone, period, end of story. Here's the thing, though... you can just about cut the cord of a lamp, solder an XLR to it, plug it into and old analog Neve input module, pad it down and get a perfect 60hz tone. Q: Why don't pedals work like that? A: Crummy frequency response, lousy signal to noise ratio and inattention to impedance match. Lack of headroom. Those are the biggies, add your own favorites to the list. That's why true bypass is so desirable, just lift all that junk outta the signal path and you have a straight shot at it again.
I know it can be made to work. If you're in the business of creating masters for duplication you know analog audio can go maybe 10 generations down before it degrades substantially... using good gear. NTSC video? One generation. I'm gonna miss NTSC.
I can't be bothered to figure out which pedals suck and which ones don't, for all practical purposes they all do. Suck tone that is, it's not the effects loop it's the pedal.
Yeah I can fix it but it took me so long to find a killer guitar and a killer amp I'm all done with my tone quest. For now.
Shoot me now, I agree with Twang!
